250
| ID | 250 |
|---|---|
| Original Title | Intuition, Rebellion and Tradition |
| Sanitized Title | intuitionrebellionandtradition |
| Clean Title | Intuition, Rebellion And Tradition |
| Source ID | 2 |
| Article Id01 | 615428494 |
| Article Id02 | oai:doaj.org/article:fe7244839d3a405a990c335001681528 |
| Corpus ID | (not set) |
| Dup | (not set) |
| Dup ID | (not set) |
| Url | https://core.ac.uk/outputs/615428494 |
| Publication Url | (not set) |
| Download Url | https://core.ac.uk/download/615428494.pdf |
| Original Abstract | Neopagans in Mexico City started to communitise only about 20 years ago. An initial analysis of related interview material shows that the narratives they develop about their first contact with neopagan content and their access to the field are framed as a conversion-like process, often connoted as a home-coming or a rebellion against predominant Catholicism. Both narratives are usually mixed with a notion of intuition that led to their further involvement in neopagan groups. Nevertheless, Mexican “folk magic” and vernacular healing traditions, Afro-American religions, and the flourishing esoteric scene in the Mexican capital are already offering links to beliefs and practices that are common in neopaganism, like ritualised ways to interact with transcendent entities, magic, and ideas of an “otherworld”. This raises various questions related to the underlying dynamics, in brief: how do heterogeneous sociohistorical situations influence emerging religious fields like the neopagan one in the Mexican capital, and how do these interactions shape personal religious transformation processes in the wider context of glocalisation, transcultural dynamics, digitalisation and the diversification of the religious field overall? In the light of Adler’s (1979) influential concept of home-coming and Luhrmann’s (1989) theory of the interpretative drift, it remains clear that becoming neopagan is rarely understood as a conversion, and therefore the two contested theoretical approaches are discussed critically and in relation to conversion. Using a grounded theory approach and thus emphasising the emic perspectives of my interviewees, I show how they construct their first encounter narratives and frame them as intuition, rebellion, or tradition, considering the underpinning sociocultural circumstances |
| Clean Abstract | (not set) |
| Tags | (not set) |
| Original Full Text | DOI: 10.46586/er.15.2024.11593License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)er.ceres.rub.deIntuition, Rebellion and TraditionFirst Encounter Narratives in Mexican NeopaganismMaria PapenfussBayreuth University, Germanyabstract Neopagans in Mexico City started to communitise only about 20 years ago.An initial analysis of related interview material shows that the narratives they developabout their first contact with neopagan content and their access to the field are framedas a conversion-like process, often connoted as a home-coming or a rebellion againstpredominant Catholicism. Both narratives are usually mixed with a notion of intuitionthat led to their further involvement in neopagan groups. Nevertheless, Mexican “folkmagic” and vernacular healing traditions, Afro-American religions, and the flourishingesoteric scene in the Mexican capital are already offering links to beliefs and practices thatare common in neopaganism, like ritualised ways to interact with transcendent entities,magic, and ideas of an “otherworld”. This raises various questions related to the underlyingdynamics, in brief: how do heterogeneous sociohistorical situations influence emergingreligious fields like the neopagan one in the Mexican capital, and how do these interactionsshape personal religious transformation processes in the wider context of glocalisation,transcultural dynamics, digitalisation and the diversification of the religious field over-all? In the light of Adler’s (1979) influential concept of home-coming and Luhrmann’s(1989) theory of the interpretative drift, it remains clear that becoming neopagan is rarelyunderstood as a conversion, and therefore the two contested theoretical approaches arediscussed critically and in relation to conversion. Using a grounded theory approach andthus emphasising the emic perspectives of my interviewees, I show how they construct theirfirst encounter narratives and frame them as intuition, rebellion, or tradition, consideringthe underpinning sociocultural circumstances.keywords neopaganism, first encounter narratives, Mexico, religious conversion,grounded theoryIntroductionThe most frequently analysed factors that have fostered the emergence of a neopagan1 religious [1]field in Mexico include digitalisation (Medina 2019–2020), a general diversification of the1 Neopaganism serves as an umbrella term for various earth-centred religiosities that include contemporarywitchcraft and heathenism as well as Norse, Germanic, Celtic, and other pre-Christian religious traditions.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)religious panorama (De la Torre, Gutiérrez, and Hernández 2020) and the positive influenceof pop-cultural productions (Calico 2018, 149–54; Gründer 2008, 52) like movies, TV-series,and games on neopagan core-tropes like the figures of the witch and the wizard in thepublic discourse. However, these analyses only survey external influences to the field anddo not account for how the active Mexican neopagans got involved in neopaganism on apersonal level in the first place. As studies from Europe (Fischer 2009; Gründer 2008, 2012;Hegner 2019; Hutton 1999, 2015; von Schnurbein 2016), the USA (Calico 2018; Harvey 1997;Hutton 1999; Lewis and Pizza 2009; York 2003), and other parts of the world (Ezzy 2009)have shown, various religious phenomena that have been categorised as neopaganism—mostprominently Wicca and Asatru—share the characteristics of decentral organisational structures,non-institutionalisation, individualisation, and a focus on personal expertise in relevant topicsas well as a historically established tendency towards secrecy. Nevertheless, the questionremains how persons with an interest in neopaganism in Mexico originally managed todiscover the existence of organised neopagan religions, what let them to delve deeper intothose topics, and how they started to build local communities. In order to trace the underlyingmotivations and initial motifs that sparked their interest and led to further involvement, I showhow neopagans in the Mexican capital narratively frame their first contact with neopaganism,thus emphasising the involved emic perspectives.Due to the fact that very little academic research has been published about neopaganism [2]in Mexico,2 the empirical data used to construct the arguments presented in this paper islimited to those neopagan groups3 and actors that have been subject to my research since2018, most prominently witchcraft-oriented Hysteria Pagana4 and Hermandad de la DiosaBlanca,5 as well as Allthing Asatru México6 with their respective founders, leaders, and coremembers. Practitioners without formal connections to established groups have been takeninto account, too. Based on a snowball-system for the selection of interlocutors due to thelow accessibility of the field and its actors, I’ve conducted narrative and semi-structuredinterviews7 and participant observation in and around Mexico City mostly during wheelof the year celebrations between 2018 and 2023 and supplemented the respective findingswith digital data recovered from webpages and social media presences.8 Since the abductiveapproach I employed, based on Glaser and Strauss’ ([1967] 2006) Grounded Theory,9 favours adynamic relation between empirical data and theory, a special emphasis is placed on the emicperspectives and object language during the coding process, leading to theoretical approaches2 Up to this date, only two papers with focus on this topic have been published: Hermosillo et al. (2016) andDe la Torre, Gutiérrez, and Dansac (2021).3 The groups that have been considered for this research are Hysteria Pagana, Allthing Asatru México,Ormbitur, Black Hat Society, Casa de la Luna, Cofradía Wicca Luna Azul, Sociedad Wicca México A. C.,Circulo Wicca México, Hermandad de la Diosa Blanca, and Espiral de Avalon.4 See https://www.facebook.com/HysteriaPagana/, last accessed May 3, 2024.5 See https://www.hdiosablanca.org/ last accessed May 3, 2024.6 See https://allthingasatrumexico.wordpress.com, last accessed May 3, 2024.7 No statistical data regarding the estimated number of neopagans in Mexico-City is available. However, thesizes of the mentioned organisations range from just a few people in the smaller groups or covens to severalhundreds of people, as in the case of Hysteria Pagana.8 The data linked to digital neopagan presences was collected on the mentioned groups’ YouTube channels,Twitter, Facebook and Instagram accounts, as well as in the following Facebook groups: “Wicca en México,”“Wicca y Neopaganismo,” “Ormbitur,” “Wicca México” and “Nordic Page MX.”9 See also Charmaz (2014).Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)closely linked to the field data.10 The categories “intuition,” “rebellion” and “tradition” aretherefore the result of the initial coding process of my empirical data.Although there is a broad range of theoretical approaches available regarding the definition [3]and process of religious transformation dynamics as in the cases considered here, I do notaim to deductively work with a particular theoretical approach. This is due to the fact thatneopaganism is often considered a religion without converts, and consequently alternativeconcepts to “conversion,” like Adler’s ([1979] 2006) home-coming and Luhrmann’s (1989)interpretative drift thesis, are more widely used in the academic study of neopaganism. WhileI discuss this critically, instead of focusing on conversion, interpretative drift, or home-comingtheory in depth, I rather analyse the portion of my empirical data that revolves aroundthe narratives related to the first encounter with neopagan topics which are usually linkedto the respective interview item,11 complemented by relevant participant observation data.The analysed material thus comprises information on personal trigger-events that led to afurther search for information and involvement in neopagan topics and groups in individualcases, shedding light on the religious transformation processes that lead towards and intoneopaganism.Consequently, this paper first discusses the idea of home-coming into a neopagan religiosity, [4]the interpretative drift theory, and why conversion theory is often discarded when studyingneopaganism. In order to contextualise the narratives, an overview of the sociocultural andsocioreligious situation in the Mexican capital is then provided, including the establishmentof the first neopagan groups that formed around the year 2000. Subsequently, I present theanalysis of the narratives regarding the first encounter with and personal transformationtowards neopaganism along three argumentative lines that I have identified as core motifs:intuition, rebellion, and tradition. Finally, the analytical findings are summarised with regardto the wider sociocultural context and implications for the further development of the Mexicanneopagan field.Theoretical Entanglements: Conversion, Home-Coming,Interpretative DriftAs a pioneer in the academic study of neopaganism in the USA and a practitioner herself,12 [5]Margot Adler stated already in 1979 in her influential book Drawing Down the Moon: Witches,Druids, Goddess-Worshippers, and Other Pagans in America Today that neopaganism is “a religionwithout converts” ([1979] 2006, title chapter 2). Discarding conversion as a viable conceptfor the approach to how neopagans acquire their identities and become part of a community,she instead coined the idea of a home-coming to a neopagan worldview, emphasising thatrather than converting to a new religion, neopagans tend to describe their “home-coming” asfinding a proper name and community for a worldview they already maintain. This concept10 Thus, the argumentation and conclusions I present below need to be considered as part of the first abductive“spirals” of the underpinning research process, that is, close to the empirical data and as starting points forfurther theorisation.11 The corresponding interview-item is “your first contact with neopaganism.” All 17 interlocutors respondedto this.12 The fact that several Religious Studies scholars who do research on neopaganism are practitioners themselveshas to be critically taken into account. See, for example, Davidsen (2012). Apart from that, many neopagansconsume academic literature on neopagan content.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)not only set the tone for practitioners’ narratives,13 but also the analytical angle in morerecent studies (Harvey 1999; Harrington 2002). Harvey later pointed out that home-comingcovers the ideas that neopagans come home to themselves, to a community, and often also aspecific tradition (1999, 239; Harrington 2002, 26). Nonetheless, Adler’s theory caused criticaldiscussions (Gallagher 1994; Reid 2009; Mayer and Gründer 2010; Anczyk and Vencálek 2013)that repeatedly revolve around her poorly developed concept of conversion, yet all referencedauthors agree that becoming neopagan is indeed described by neopagans mostly as some kindof “coming home.” This is not surprising, as different variations of the home-coming narrativeplay a central role in various conversion theories regarding a wide range of religions.14But why do both neopagans and religious scholars for the most part reject conversion both [6]conceptually and rhetorically? In line with Adler’s ([1979] 2006) still prevailing influence onneopagan conversion discourses, the idea of conversion is embedded in Christian tradition,prominently displayed in Saint Augustine’s Confessions15 and the biblical account of Saul’sconversion. This often leads to the assumption of conversion as a rupture or radical change,among other features based on Christianity-related case studies, and derived concepts oftenunintentionally maintain latent Christian connotations. This is not only problematic whennon-Christian or non-European religious phenomena are concerned, but also in the specific caseof neopaganism with a notably critical if not adversarial attitude towards it. Such dismissiveopinions are often argumentatively tied to the European history of forced Christianisationof Norse and Germanic tribes in late Antiquity and the witch trials as well as the Inquisitionduring the Middle Ages (Hutton 2015, 13). Apart from the problematic Christian tinge of theoriginal notion itself, its focus on a radical rupture and binary change on a personal level omitsother relevant perspectives on individual religious transformation, such as their processualand continuous nature and cultural embeddedness. Several attempts to broaden the concepthave been made, yet in the field of the academic study of neopaganism, other concepts becamemore widely used.Although more focused on magic practitioners than neopagans in general, Tanya Luhrmann’s [7](1989) controversial interpretative drift concept is frequently discussed as the counter positionto the home-coming hypothesis and the idea of conversion in the narrow sense explained above(Mayer and Gründer 2010; Harrington 2002, 26). Interpretative drift describes the processduring which neopagans gradually establish their (magical) beliefs based on meaningfulsubjective experiences and how they develop strategies of rationalization for those beliefsand their efficacy (Luhrmann 1989, 312–14; Mayer and Gründer 2010, 3). Focusing on theexperiential dimension of becoming neopagan, Luhrmann underlines the processual characterof the personal transformation of becoming—and identifying as—a neopagan. Analysing therelation of the interpretative drift and home-coming theses, Mayer and Gründer conclude thatboth are in fact complementary and identify “… (a) the feeling and experience of cominghome, (b) the process of interpretative drift, and (c) extraordinary experiences containingstrongly subjective evidence” (2010, 15) as three important facets that characterise the processof becoming a magic practitioner, and in their wider perspective also a neopagan.16 Thus, they13 See, for example, non-academic literature like Diane Smith’s “Wicca and Witchcraft for Dummies” (2005),especially “Part III: Coming Home: How Wiccans Become Wiccans”.14 Han (Han 2019), for example, calls this process based on his study of young Asians who become Buddhists“reversion.”15 In his thirteen-part autobiography, the later sainted Augustine of Hippo narrates his conversion to Chris-tianity. His account had a major influence on the idea of conversion and tied it to a Christian context.16 Mayer and Gründer (2010) as well as Luhrmann (1989) first and foremost refer to magic practitioners,however, in both cases the authors extend their theories to neopagans in general. The resulting conceptualPapenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)recognise the interpretative drift and the home-coming idea as different approaches to thesame individual transformation process, adding meaningful personal experiences, e.g. dreamsor encounters with transcendent entities like gods, as a third influential factor. In the samecomplementary sense, Berger and Ezzy (2007) highlight that although the prevalent notion ofhome-coming rightfully underlines the agency of neopagans as individual seekers, the culturalenvironment and especially mass media also influence this process considerably. They evenpoint out that the… phrase “coming home” and all that it implies can itself be understood as a [8]conversion narrative, that is, a culturally constructed rhetorical device throughwhich individuals attempt to explain themselves and others why they changedreligions or joined a religion after being unaffiliated. (Berger and Ezzy 2007, 58–59)In line with their observations, the tendency to analyse neopagan conversion narratives from a [9]variety of premises, especially those that focus on conversion as a continuous process, externalsociocultural circumstances like mass media, meaningful subjective experiences and othersignificant factors, going beyond the narrow idea of conversion Adler initially referred to,seems to present a fruitful approach among the referenced authors. The emic perspectivespresented in the respective studies show that many neopagans do not understand themselvesas converts, rendering “conversion” a rather superimposed label from their perspectives. Thisunderlines the substantial differences between practitioners’ understandings of the conceptand more recent approaches to conversion by scholars who make an effort to develop moresensitive, e.g., de-colonial theoretical concepts.Following a Grounded Theory based research design, I chose to approach the question of [10]how my interlocutors became neopagans through the narratives they develop about their firstencounter with neopaganism, considering external influences like sociocultural circumstances,especially mass media, and internal influences like decisive experiences, without mentioning“conversion” in order to avoid the possible negative connotations of the concept. Analytically,I thus take key elements identified by the aforementioned authors into account, yet usethe codes abstracted from the empirical data as the main conceptual axis. The developedcategories are therefore the result of abductive coding rather than deductive theoretical work,and consequently maintain close proximity to the empirical data on purpose. As the termconversión was thoroughly avoided by my interlocutors, I chose “first encounter narratives” asan analytical label, encouraging a conceptual inclusion into narration-focussed conversiontheories like Jindra’s17 (2011) approach.Without pre-empting the analysis, it must be added that what Luhrmann describes with [11]her interpretative drift, i.e., a processual development of beliefs and their rationalisation,emphasising the experiential dimension and processual character thereof, plays a major rolein the narratives I categorise as “Intuition.” As expected, due to the huge impact of thehome-coming narrative among both practitioners and scholars, the idea of coming home to aneopagan self, community, and tradition also serves as a core element of both the “Intuition”and “Tradition” narratives as it highlights the continuity many interlocutors point out regardingthe development of their religious identity.ambiguities does not play a role here because the majority of the interviewees can be described as magicpractitioners, as illustrated in some interview excerpts below.17 She interprets conversion processes based on narrative biographic interview material and analyses “push”and “pull” factors, e.g., the biographical/sociocultural background of a person and what she calls “religiouscontent,” as well as the interaction between these factors.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)The following overview of the sociocultural context in which the first formal neopagan [12]groups emerged in the Mexican capital sets the stage for the subsequent analysis.Neopaganism in Mexico CityMexico is rightfully known for its particular version of Catholicism, and the official census from [13]2020 shows that 75.9 % of Mexico City’s residents identified as Catholics at this time (INEGI2022, 133). However, as De la Torre et al. (2020) argue, global tendencies like digitalisation,decentralisation, an increase in transcultural exchange, and heightened environmental aware-ness have given rise to a broader variety of religious phenomena as a reaction to the relatedgrowing challenges, resulting in diversification and an overall reconfiguration of the Mexicanreligious panorama during the last decades. In this context, the upsurge of neopaganism can beconsidered symptomatic, especially due to the known cybercultural affinity among neopagansever since the popularisation of the internet (Cowan 2005). Although the emerging neopaganfield in the Mexican capital is still in an early stage of its development in comparison toother regions, and communitarisation only started around the year 2000, a variety of more orless formally organised groups tied to religious traditions like Wicca and Asatru have beenestablished since then. Not only are the corresponding religiosities locally (re)configured witha focus on the individual and in reaction to the rapidly changing sociocultural context, butthey also offer continuities with a wide range of already existing traditions. Among thoseare over sixty indigenous religions on Mexican soil as well as Afro-American religions, localvernacular healing traditions, so-called folk magic, and a variety of Christian beliefs. The moreobvious, predominant, and historically traceable references, however, are pre-Christian andcontemporary European cultures as they are considered to be the socio-cultural base or serveas a central inspiration for beliefs and practices.In a sociocultural context characterised by Christianity, especially the Catholic Church, [14]neopagan core concepts like magic and the stereotypes of the witch and the wizard in modernWicca and witchcraft traditions or the Blót-ritual and the Viking warrior stereotype in Norseand Germanic religious traditions tend to be negatively framed as inherently opposed to thepredominant values and worldviews in public discourse. Thus, those main concepts are oftenlinked to satanism, demon- and devil-worship, illicit and malicious magical practice (oftenso-called “black magic”), and counter-cultural ideologies in mass and Catholic media, givingthem a negative connotation there.18 Although ambivalent ties to those publicly discreditedtopics can indeed be identified within the current neopagan fields, people interested in them18 In order to briefly illustrate this tendency, the translated headlines of representative newspaper articlesfrom Aciprensa, a Catholic news outlet, as well as El Universal and Milenio, two influential Mexicannewspapers, should suffice here: “Is Karely Ruiz a victim of witchcraft? Work against her found buried in acemetery.” (Milenio, 03.08.2022, last accessed May 3, 2024. URL: https://www.milenio.com/virales/karely-ruiz-hallan-trabajo-brujeria-contra-ella-en-panteon-video); “Exorcists warn of dangers of following‘modern witch’ trend.” (Aciprensa, 20.07.2022, last accessed May 3, 2024. URL: https://www.aciprensa.com/noticias/exorcistas-advierten-los-peligros-de-seguir-la-moda-de-las-brujas-modernas-56866);“Divination, charms and witchcraft open door to the devil, warns priest.” (Aciprensa, 27.08.2019, lastaccessed May 3, 2024. URL: https://www.aciprensa.com/noticias/adivinacion-amuletos-y-brujeria-abren-puerta-al-demonio-advierte-sacerdote-76940); “New cardinal who was an exorcist for 20 yearsteaches to live a faith free of ‘new paganism’.” (Aciprensa, 26.07.2022, last accessed May 3, 2024. URL:https://www.aciprensa.com/noticias/nuevo-cardenal-que-fue-exorcista-por-20-anos-ensena-a-vivir-una-fe-libre-del-nuevo-paganismo-31360); “Catholics angered by ‘Little Demon’ series on Disney-ownedchannel. The faithful feel they can no longer even trust the ‘suitable for all audiences’ label.” (El Universal,07.09.2022, last accessed May 3, 2024. URL: https://www.eluniversal.com.mx/espectaculos/enoja-catolicos-serie-de-la-hija-de-satan-en-un-canal-propiedad-de-disney)Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)during the time when neopaganism in Mexico City was not yet formally organised not only hadto deal with the associated prevalent prejudices in their social circles but were also confrontedwith a lack of relevant sources in Spanish. In consequence, this led them to mostly Europeanand US-American source material in foreign languages. As a matter of fact, prominent pop-cultural productions like “Harry Potter,” “Ghost Whisperer,” “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina,”and “Charmed” have in turn contributed to shifting the public connotations of the respectivetropes, presenting them as positive and empowering, and therefore creating possible points ofentry into the neopagan field.19A last observation about the specific case of cultural phenomena in Mexico that are strongly [15]related to “Western” (i.e., European and US-American) traditions has to be made due to thecolonial history of the country and what is commonly known as malinchismo:20 the tendency inMexican culture to hold foreign things and ideas in higher esteem than Mexican ones. Althoughthe underlying tendencies of exoticism and xenophilia might hint at superficial reasons for thefascination with pre-Christian European traditions, they can only account for one generalisedfactor among the many that influence the sociocultural and religious dynamics that lead therelevant individuals to a deeper involvement with those cultures on a personal level. Therefore,the concrete individual narratives are analysed in the following.Core Elements of First Encounter NarrativesOne of the central items taken up by the interviewees during the first round of interviews is [16]the “first contact with neopaganism.” In response, the interlocutors not only elaborated theback stories of how they became neopagans and their first encounter narratives themselves,but also embellished stories of experiences with deities, energy, magic, or the “call” towards anon-Catholic religion, consequently offering explanations for their search for information andcommunity around them. The three guiding narratives that crystallised out of the interviewsare presented below as an empirical basis for further abductive analysis. The resulting cate-gorisation is based on the motivation(s) and context(s) given by the interviewees, resulting inthree approaches: intuition, rebellion, and tradition. As they are not mutually exclusive, theindividual narratives all contain elements of two or of all three.IntuitionJenny,21 who calls herself a “progressive Wicca,” says that although she was raised as a [17]Christian and had consequently celebrated baptism and confirmation, she never identified withthe Catholic religion because “something else was always calling”22 her and she had thereforealready resigned herself to the fact that it was better not to belong to any religion at all, alsobecause she could not find any tangible connection with exactly what was “calling” her. Sheemphasises that she has always had a vague intuition since childhood: “… so somehow there19 The positive impact of mass media on the development and growth of neopagan fields is analysed in moredetail by various authors, see for example Berger & Ezzy (2007).20 Derived from the historical figure Malinche, interpreter and advisor to the Spanish conqueror Hernán Cortés.She was a native Nahua and is considered a stereotypical traitor to the Mexican indigenous population dueto the fact that she helped the Spaniards conquer Tenochtitlan. Malinchismo thus polemically refers to thebetrayal of Mexican culture by Mexicans themselves, especially to those who value what is foreign overwhat is Mexican. In the extreme, this attitude can be understood as Latin American auto-racism.21 All names of the interviewees have been changed so that their identity remains anonymous.22 Original: … siempre me llamaba algo más.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)was something, but I don’t know exactly what it was.”23 She speaks of a llamado, a call, whichshe describes as a feeling of having to follow a certain path. In detail:The path calls you, but you only follow this call when you are ready for it. [… [18]There] were many occasions in my life that connected me to it, but I paid littleattention to them because I grew up with this belief—or rather, because this beliefwas drilled into me—that witches are of the devil.24 […] I then discovered all thisover time. But what caught my attention the most, and this sounds quite simple atbest or [laughs] a bit silly, well, were pop-cultural films and series.25She mentions the TV series “Ghost Whisperer” as an example for pop-cultural sources of [19]inspiration, because she picked up the term “Wicca” there for the first time and later searchedfor it on the internet. However, she found little useful information at the time. It was not untilmany years later (around 2013) that she returned to the subject of Wicca, again pop-culturallyinspired by the movie “The Craft.” She searched the internet yet again and actually foundmore information and a concrete connection, in this case to the Mexico City-based neopaganorganisation Hysteria Pagana, where she is now a core member. The similarities to Berger andEzzy’s (2007) findings regarding the importance of mass media products that shed a positivelight on neopaganism, as well as the idea of a home-coming, become apparent here.Just like Jenny, other interviewees recount an intuition, a feeling, or an urge that directed [20]their interest towards neopaganism, which they classify in the first instance as an experienceor impactful thought without linking any specific external influences to it. Following thisinternal “call,” they embarked on a quest26 for information and community, which in turnactually led them to tangible literature, people, and groups. Dominic illustrates this as follows:Ever since I was little, I knew that something was different about me. I had dreams [21]that involved Freya and feral landscapes full of snow and wild pinewoods—thingsI couldn’t make sense of at the time, but which felt somehow familiar, homely.From there on, a yearning developed, a kind of… secret quest. My friends did nothave something like that. Later, when I learned more about the Norse gods, manythings became clear to me that I had only begun to guess at as a child.27The same motive of intuition that Dominic uses to explain him being drawn to neopaganism is [22]used to frame his journey into neopaganism later in his life as the kind of home-coming Adler([1979] 2006) and Harvey (1997) point out, while also leaning heavily on the meaningfulsubjective experience Mayer and Gründer (2010) highlight, which in this case refers to dreams.23 Original: … pues es que hay algo más allí, pero no sé qué es.24 “Of the devil” is but one possible translation of the Spanish term del diablo, which has satanic and overallevil connotations in public discourse.25 Original: … el camino te llama, pero hasta que estas listo como que atiendes el llamado. […] fueron muchasocasiones en mi vida que me vinculaban con esto y no les presté mucha atención, porque pues yo crecí con estacreencia, o bueno, nos inculcan esta creencia de que las brujas son del diablo […]. [F]ue como descubrir todoconforme fue pasando el tiempo. Pero es que lo que más me llamó, y va a sonar a lo mejor medio simple [se ríe] oa lo mejor un poco tonto, pues fueron películas y series de la cultura pop.26 In their respective conversion models, Lofland/Stark (1965) and Straus (1976), among others, would labelthose persons as “seekers” as they try to solve a tension in their lives by seeking a (religious) solution. Thislabel, however, falls short of the emphasis the quoted interlocutors place on pivotal encounters that werenot sought after at all, as exemplified below.27 Original: Desde chiquito sabía que yo era algo diferente. Tuve sueños con Freya y paisajes llenos de nieve y bosqueboreal – cosas que ni sabía clasificar en este momento, pero de alguna manera se sintieron acogedores. De ellasse desarrolló un anhelo, una especie de… búsqueda secreta. Mis amigos no tuvieron esto. Más adelante, cuandoconocí más sobre los dioses nórdicos, entendí mucho de lo que de niño solo había intuido.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)Other interlocutors also describe unintended encounters that brought them into contact with [23]specific neopagan content that they had not previously known. Penelope, for example, reportsan occasion that happened while she was suffering a depressive episode: she had perceived anunknown woman on the edge of her bed one night who told her that she was there for her andthat she should not worry. Penelope picked up the name “Hecate” from this encounter, whichshe claimed she had not known before, searched it on Google and found out that she wasdealing with the Greek goddess Hecate whose images resembled the woman she had seen onher bed. In the following, she had strived to find out more about this goddess and, in the widercontext, also about Wicca, and finally decided to become initiated as a Wiccan priestess lateron. As Mayer and Gründer argue, the extraordinary experience “containing strongly subjectiveevidence” (2010, 15), in this case the encounter with the goddess Hecate, triggers a deeperinvolvement with neopaganism, and this process reflects, on the one hand, what Luhrmann(1989) describes as interpretative drift insofar as it includes processes of rationalisation and“growing into” a Wiccan priestess; on the other hand, it matches the idea of coming home intoa community of likeminded people after years of searching, but also into a self-image andlabel that properly represents how she understands herself. In accordance with Pike’s findingsabout neopagans in the USA, first encounter narratives often include “childhood visions of thedivine in nature and encounters with unusual phenomena such as ghosts” (2001, 165) thatmark a crucial point for their religious self-identification.The intuition of a hitherto foreign, neopagan world is identified here as a pronounced motive [24]which the interviewees use not only to justify their involvement with neopaganism, but alsoto contextualise and interpret it. The narratives that revolve around the first encounter withneopaganism through an intuition rely heavily on situations that are interpreted as meaningfuland pivotal by the practitioners and often include altered states of mind like dreams. In turn,the second motive, rebellion, is not predominantly based on subjective experience and thought,but on narratives about a tangible everyday social life. The passive, experience-based conceptof intuition thus in a sense opposes, and in some cases complements, the active, action-basedconcept of rebellion.RebellionA second leitmotif in the narratives concerning the interviewees’ first encounters with neopa- [25]ganism is their resistance against Roman Catholic discourses that were (and still mostly are)dominant in Mexican society, and are usually reproduced among their families and broadersocial circles. Although the majority of the interlocutors distance themselves from RomanCatholicism or Christianity in general, not all of them adopt a fundamentally rebellious at-titude towards Christianity. However, the rebellion motive is not characterised by a merelypassive distancing from the Catholic Church or Christianity, but rather an actively voicedcounter-position that is acted upon. This position becomes clear in situations like my encounterwith Selena, an Alexandrian Wicca I met for an informal interview in autumn 2018. When wewalked past a Jehovah’s Witnesses information table in a Metro station, she reacted to thetwo women’s invitation to a quick talk by vigorously pointing at her T-shirt that featured thevibrantly coloured lettering “We are the granddaughters of the Witches you couldn’t burn”28and flashing them a provocative smile, thus clearly indicating her aversion.The narratives about any kind of rebellion are characterised by the respective interviewees [26]28 Translated from the Spanish original Somos las nietas de las brujas que no pudisteis quemar.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)as starting in their childhood or adolescence and flattening out during adulthood with theadoption of a genuine neopagan identity, implying their becoming more reflective and lessimpulsive. Yet, the initial motive remains an act of personal rebellion. Meredith, for instance,opens her encounter with neopaganism by narrating this anecdote:My mother was a Catholic and I think it was passed down like that from generation [27]to generation and that is why they wanted to imprint that on me […], but I wasnever interested, I never felt comfortable with it. No. I didn’t like going to church,as we usually had to, and I felt kind of bad at church. So, I avoided it. I remembermy mother telling my brother and I when we were teenagers that we should goto church; if we did not, we would not go out for dinner afterwards or somethinglike that. “From the Sunday service we will go to this or that place.” And I waslike: “No, forget it.” No. Never. That is, I never felt part of it. It just did not findanything in it at all.29The uneasy feeling about the Catholic Church, paired with a parent-imposed obligation to [28]interact with Roman Catholic content—primarily churchgoing, monotheistic dogma, andthe Roman Catholic organisational structure, especially its hierarchies—shape the rebellionnarrative. The majority of my interlocutors also actively resigned from church if they wereformally affiliated as children by their parents. It must be stressed that the correspondinginterviewees rebelled against Roman Catholic socialisation from childhood or adolescenceonwards and, in the cases of three of them, actively pursued practices and world views thatwere deemed contrary to the predominant value systems, e.g., Satanism or Paganism.30 Theythen consciously exhibited these practices and worldviews in public and private. The means ofchoice to express their rebellion, apart from the corresponding religious activities, were mainlyattire and accessories with symbols such as the pentagram, triple moon, Vegvesir, Mjölnir, andothers commonly used by neopagans, as well as music, often tied to Gothic and Metal musicsubcultures, Satanism, Occultism, and Esotericism, including their typical stylistic elements.The arguments that support the rebellion narratives tend to reproduce negative discourses [29]about Roman Catholicism and are aimed less at a dissociation from the Catholic Church butrather at actively choosing neopaganism over it. Aurora exemplifies this:One has heard of so many abuses and it feels as if [Roman Catholicism] is always [30]a religion that causes a lot of fear, right? And so I think that now people want tobe a bit freer and want to know a bit more about the truth, right? So they do notwant to be, well, so that there is… not so much punishment […]. And that it canbe a bit freer.3129 Original: … mi mamá era católica y creo que esto ha sido de generación en generación y pues es como que lo queme quisieron inculcar. […] pero nunca me llamó la atención, o sea, no, como que no estaba yo a gusto. No. Nome gustaba entrar en una iglesia, como siempre, como que me sentía mal. Entonces lo evitaba. Me acuerdo que yamás como que de adolescente, mi mamá, a mi hermano y a mí nos decía que fuéramos a la iglesia, si no, no nosiban a llevar a comer fuera o no sé. ¿No? “De allí de misa vamos a tal lugar” y yo así de “no”, o sea, “olvídalo”.No. Nunca, no sé, no me, no me sentía parte de esto. Como que no le encontraba yo el chiste.30 Two interviewees mentioned Anton LaVey’s Satanism, one named Camino Rojo as examples.31 Original: Se han escuchado de tantos abusos y como que siempre [el catolicismo] es una religión que meten comomucho miedo, ¿no? Y entonces como que yo pienso que ahora las personas quieren ser un poco más libres y quierencomo saber un poco más la verdad, ¿no? De que no estar, pues que no… hay tanto castigo […]. Y puede ser unpoco más libre.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)The connection she draws between neopaganism and freedom and, in contrast, the Catholic [31]Church and fear and punishment is similarly found in other interviews. The Catholic Churchas an institution as well as the value system conveyed by it are consequently accused ofbeing too dogmatic and institutionalised, especially their hierarchical organisational struc-ture and attributed (moral) rigidity. These accusations usually also describe the CatholicChurch as intolerant, outdated, misogynistic, patriarchal, fear-inducing, and too focused onproselytisation. Those attributes are then used to justify turning to neopaganism in searchof a viable alternative. One striking aspect of this argumentation is that by contrasting thenegative attributes ascribed to the Catholic Church, the ideas, organisational structures, andvalues ascribed to neopaganism are in turn inherently framed as the better option. Hence,this narrative leads to the conclusion that rebellion against a negatively connoted religionhas the logical consequence of turning to a religion that embodies the opposite values—inthis case, any kind of neopaganism. Further points in favour, prominently mentioned by theinterviewees who talk about their rebellion against the prevailing social system, include thefollowing points:32• An emphasis on female empowerment, especially in light of the growing number of [32]femicides in Mexico.• Nature protection and sustainability, tied to their pan-, polytheistic, or animistic world- [33]views and the derived ethical and moral value systems that are frequently linked toholistic ideas.• The lack of missionary tendencies towards non-neopagans, underpinning their open [34]criticism against those actors in civil society that try to convert them to their religion orideological view.• The opportunity to create individual, local traditions that overcome ideas and structures [35]which emerged in a colonial setting where the local population, frequently highlightedas venerated ancestors by the interviewees, was forced to convert to Christianity.The rebellion narratives also illustrate the latent criticism of conversion as a concept related to [36]Christianity and colonial history, especially one that frames the converted person as a passiverecipient rather than an individual with agency, much in the sense of Adler ([1979] 2006),Reid (2009, 172), and Anczyk/Vencálek (2013, 165).“Tradition,” the third narrative motif regarding the initial encounter with neopaganism, [37]presents yet a different approach, since Christian socialisation plays only a secondary role inthis line of argumentation. In turn, prior influences of a religiously heterogeneous or overtly“magical” or “spiritual” family context form the centre of the respective arguments analysedbelow.TraditionFive of the seventeen interlocutors emphasised having grown up in family circumstances [38]where magical practices and beliefs that align with those interpreted as neopagan formed animportant part of everyday life during their childhood and adolescence. Points of intersection32 It would go beyond the scope of this paper to elaborate further on those points, yet they only touch thesurface of crucial developments within neopaganism that require further research.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)between those world views and their individual configurations of neopaganism are above allfolk magic and vernacular healing practices, African-American religions such as Santería andPalo Mayombe, and indigenous Mexican world views like those of the Maya, Nahua, Mexica,and Mazahua people.The clearest example of the tradition narrative is provided by Aurora, who reports that her [39]first contact with neopaganism took place “… when I was little. […] I did not even know whatneopaganism was, but my father, well, he did purification and shamanic rituals at home andtogether with a witch.”33 She says these practices were considered “normal” at home and thatlater, around the age of twenty to twenty-five, she developed an active interest in witchcraftand magic, and subsequently pursued it herself. Penelope also explains that she has familymembers who are Catholic Christians and from various other religions, including Mayan, who:… not only believe in the supernatural, but also have gifts.34 For example: my [40]maternal grandmother can predict the future. My mother levitates things whenshe gets angry. […] My sister is a medium. […] So it has always been like a topicin my family. […] And I started to make my own potions when I was little.35The “supernatural” ideas she later takes up in what she calls progressive Wicca, she has [41]already related to since childhood, and her contact with Wicca occurred primarily throughher continued preoccupation with the “supernatural” and possible ways of interacting with it.Even if she does not engage in the exact same practices as her family members, she was bornand raised into religious traditions characterised by many elements that are equally prevalentin neopaganism: an “otherworld”, magic and sorcery, communication with transcendentnon-human beings, spirit, gods, poly- as well as pantheism, and the like.Adriana and Mateo also relate stories of core moments when they received worldview-related [42]explanations from their parents or grandparents who brought them into direct contact with amagical, supernatural reality and entities that were interpreted as dwellers of a dimensionother than the material realm. When she discovered what supposedly was an unusually fast-blinking firefly in the garden of her grandparents as a child, Adriana states that she askedher grandfather for an explanation and that he showed her in response “… how to open thisthird eye, and told me: ‘Take a good look at her, that is a fairy.’ ”36 She highlights that hersocialisation inherently contained elements she later interpreted as neopagan; in this case,fairies and the “otherworld.”Mateo directly links his approach to herbalism and folk magic practices to the genetic lineage [43]of his ancestors, stressing their function as a common ground with Wiccan practice and amagical worldview in general. His maternal grandmother was a curandera (natural healer) whoalso performed folk magic practices such as limpias (spiritual cleansings), and it was throughhis mother that “… the tradition was then passed on, right? Through the genes as well. […] Ifeel that this was my first contact. And later I started to seek and search and investigate onmy own.”37 In this case, too, attention is drawn to a line of tradition that not only suggests33 Original: … fue de pequeña […]. Yo ni sabía lo que era neopaganismo, pero con mi papá, porque él practicabacomo rituales de limpia y rituales chamánicos allí en la casa, si, con una bruja.34 The Spanish term don she uses also refers to talents and skills, and may allude to supernatural abilities as isthis case.35 Original: … no solo creen en lo sobrenatural, sino que tienen dones. Por ejemplo: mi abuelita materna puedepredecir el futuro. Mi mamá, cuando se enoja, levita cosas. […] Mi hermana es médium. […] Entonces desdesiempre ha sido como un tema en mi familia. […] luego empecé yo de chiquita a hacer mis pociones.36 Original: … cómo abrir este tercer ojo y me dijo: “Véla bien, es un hada.”37 Original: … se va pasando, ¿no? Entre los genes también. […] Yo siento que desde allí fue mi primer contacto.Posteriormente pues yo empecé a buscar y buscar e indagar.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)an upbringing that harmonises with neopagan ideas but also explains certain abilities, forinstance skills in magic, herbalism, and spiritual healing, through a genetic lineage.38Although framed differently than in the previous example, Mariela also ascribes herself to [44]a religious tradition that assumes a magical dimension because the majority of her familyis affiliated to the Afro-Cuban religion Santería. Moreover, she speaks of having “gifts” andconnects this idea to her heritage in terms of worldviews that were passed down through herancestors and living family members. The “gifts” she identifies include the communicationwith supernatural entities, channelling energy and working magic. In comparison to the otherexamples, she does not place herself in the concrete family tradition of Santería, but distancesherself from it. However, the orientation towards a magical worldview remains and is used byher to explain her search for like-minded persons in order to properly deal with her “gifts”:… I never practised them [the gifts], but I was always aware that I would have [45]to deal with them if they became too invasive. That is because when you havethem, they suddenly become quite invasive in your life until you accept them orgo crazy.39She explains the decisive factor for further involvement with neopaganism as a necessity to [46]avoid going “crazy,” apart from her more obvious link to the “supernatural” due to her beingraised in a Santería-based world-view.The narratives in which the interviewees locate themselves in a tradition that contains [47]elements that directly interact with their idea of neopaganism frame their turn to a neopaganreligion on the one hand as a logical or necessary consequence of an already acquired world-view, and on the other hand as a strategy for coping with an everyday reality that containselements like an “otherworld,” as well as related energies and entities that form the centre oftheir individual configuration of a neopagan religiosity.As “tradition” continues to be a controversially discussed topic among both neopagans and [48]scholars (Rountree 2015; Magliocco 2004), especially regarding the negotiation of authenticity,it is not surprising that my interlocutors talk about becoming neopagan as carrying on atradition. Yet, neither of the theoretical approaches introduced in the first part of this articleconsiders the “tradition” approach as a kind of “conversion,” as there is neither a ruptureregarding core elements in the respective worldview nor an interpretative drift, but ratherthe active decision to follow an already familiar worldview while interpreting, utilising, andadapting its elements in a highly individual way.ConclusionsTrying to avoid the ambiguities of conversion theories and the entailing conceptual difficulties [49]known in the field of neopaganism, this paper focused on first encounter narratives in orderto trace how individuals describe themselves as becoming neopagans. In the case of theinterviewed Mexican neopagans, the transformation processes are often understood as “cominghome” to the “right” religion, as a gradual and active process. Although the individual38 This is not uncommon in neopaganism. Stephen McNallen, an influential US-American author in the field ofNorse and Germanic heathenism, prominently coined the controversial concept of Metagenetics that ties theauthenticity of North American neopagans to their ancestral lineage from Europe (see Calico 2018, 175).39 Original: … nunca las practiqué, pero siempre estaba consciente de que en algún momento de mi vida si estuvierancomo que muy invasivas, yo los tuviera que pelar. Porque cuando las tienes, de pronto se vuelven muy invasivas entu vida hasta que los aceptes o te vuelves loco.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)approaches to neopaganism are framed differently in the interviewees’ narratives, all of themcontain at least one motif based on which they explain their search for concrete access andconnections and subsequently their integration into the neopagan community, usually alsointo a particular group. One of the central ideas is an intuition based on concrete experiences,thoughts, dreams, or visions that the interlocutors describe as a fundamental feeling that isimposed on them and has to be dealt with, thus placing related and connectable neopaganideas in the centre of their religious interest. However, there are individually differing variantsof this intuition; the motif of returning home to a neopagan culture and that of an intimateconnection to a neopagan deity or (Northern) European culture without having known eitherof them beforehand are two meaningful examples. These encounters are often linked to dreamsand visions, that is, altered states of consciousness that do not correspond to a regular mindstate. Apart from that, the intuition is described as a latent abstract feeling experienced as alonging or a “call” towards something different than the ordinary and known, which sooneror later leads to concrete involvement with neopaganism.Two other tendencies become evident in the empirical material: that of an active rebellion [50]against a Catholic education and the associated worldviews, dogmas, power relations, and rites,on the one hand, and that of the pursuit of a magical tradition or, less specifically, the adoptionof a worldview deemed “normal” by the family which already contains meaningful elementsthat the interviewees interpret as neopagan, for example polytheism, magic, or shamanism,on the other hand. In both cases, the encounter with neopagan contents is presented as aconscious decision or as a reaction to an upbringing within a certain ideological framework,which is either followed (tradition) or opposed (rebellion) to a certain extent, leading to theconfiguration of individualised neopagan religiosities.It must be stressed that these three tendencies are not mutually exclusive. On the contrary, [51]the majority of my interlocutors recount both an emotional, experiential, and intuitive approachmostly during their childhood or adolescence, but then highlight that their active decision infavour of neopaganism occurred in the context of, and therefore as a reaction to, prevailingsocio-cultural-religious circumstances. Those are mainly shaped by Mexican Catholicism, moreoften than not interpreted in the light of colonial history, and the entailing public Christiandiscourse wherein core neopagan tropes remain negatively connoted. Opposing discursiveforces that reassign positive connotations to emblematic neopagan content comprise not onlyfolk-religious and herbalist practices as well as indigenous and Afro-American traditions thatoffer substantial points of connection, but also entertainment franchises that shed a positive, ifnot heroic light on stereotypes that inspire and shape core ideas taken up in neopaganism likethe Viking warrior, the spirit medium, or the witch with their respective idealised lifestyles. Asa consequence and in line with Ezzy and Berger’s (2007) findings, the rise of the internet canbe understood as a main catalyst for neopagan communitarisation in the Mexican capital: itoffered access to information on existing traditions of interest and anonymous communicationplatforms where interested persons could interact with like-minded people without having totravel abroad to establish personal contact with existing foreign neopagan groups40 and withouthaving to fear the negative stigmatisation they may have suffered in their predominantlyChristian social circles, in spite of the already broadening and diversifying Mexican religiouspanorama.40 The interview data shows that Mexican neopagans in leading positions, like the founders of Allthing AsatruMexico and Hysteria Pagana, have established ties to European and US-American neopagans mostly asteachers or mentors. Yet most interlocutors have not had any contact or relationship with foreign actors atall due to their self-declared economic incapacity to afford a trip abroad.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)The three identified first encounter narratives are embedded in complex sociohistorical [52]and cultural entanglements, and therefore reflect the underlying societal power relations andresulting religious configurations in a merely exemplary and simplified way. They still offerinsights into the reasons why Mexican neopagans initially decided to proactively engage inneopaganism and how they make sense of their religious trajectory so far, highlighting thesubsequent developments as results of arising religious demands. The three categories can thusbe understood as narrative framings of personal approaches and entries into the neopaganfield as well as the underlying reasons, motives, and triggers as follows:• Intuition: fundamental feeling of belonging based on personal experiences related to [53]thoughts, dreams or visions of transcendent entities and relevant foreign cultures, oftenchildhood-related and understood as a latent “call”, later labelled as coming home.• Rebellion: active, action-based, often counter-culturally framed opposition against the [54]prevalent social norms, mostly Christianity (Catholicism), often visually expressed andacted out during adolescence.• Tradition: continuation of an ancestral lineage or family tradition related to core [55]elements of neopagan practice and world-view, often genealogically framed.These narratives point towards further communitarisation processes as reactions to the short- [56]comings and an increasing demand for information and formal communities. The lack thereofcan be interpreted as a principal motivation for those persons who are now main actors in theMexican neopagan field to found organisations, covens, and clans, set up educational offerslike seminars and workshops, libraries, later also websites and presences on digital socialplatforms. They even strive to become more visible in the public, for example through eventslike a yearly pagan pride parade and commercial establishments like shops, cafés, and eventsthat cater specifically to a neopagan clientele. It becomes clear that further investigation isnot only necessary in order to trace the developments of the ephemeral and fluid emergingneopagan field in the Mexican capital and nationwide, but also to discover the underlyingglocal41 relations and relationalities that influence the ongoing processes of (re)configurationand shape individual neopagan religiosities.ReferencesAdler, Margot. (1979) 2006. Drawing Down the Moon. Witches, Druids, Goddessworshippers, andOther Pagans in America Today. London: Penguin.Anczyk, Adam, and Matouš Vencálek. 2013. “Coming Home to Paganism: Theory of ReligiousConversion or a Theological Principle?” Studia Religiologica 46 (3): 161–71.Berger, Helen A., and Douglas Ezzy. 2007. Teenage Witches. Magical Youth and the Search forthe Self. Piscataway / London: Rutgers University Press.Calico, Jefferson F. 2018. Being Viking. Heathenism in Contemporary America. Bristol: EquinoxPublishing.Charmaz, Kathy. 2014. Constructing Grounded Theory. London: SAGE.Cowan, Douglas E. 2005. Cyberhenge. Modern pagans on the Internet. New York / London:Routledge.41 Regarding interdependent global and local factors.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)Davidsen, Markus A. 2012. “What is Wrong with Pagan Studies?” Method and Theory in theStudy of Religion 24: 183–99.De la Torre, Renée, Cristina Gutiérrez, and Yael Dansac. 2021. “The cultural effects of neo-paganism’s ritual creativity.” Ciencias Sociales y Religión 23: 1–21.De la Torre, Renée, Cristina Gutiérrez, and Alberto Hernández. 2020. “Religious reconfigurationin Mexico: Beliefs and Practices National Survey, 2016.” Social Compass 67 (3): 349–71.Ezzy, Douglas. 2009. “Australian Paganisms.” In Handbook of Contemporary Paganism, editedby James R. Lewis and Murphy Pizza. Leiden / Boston: Brill.Fischer, Kathrin. 2009. “Das Wiccatum in Deutschland.” In Der andere Glaube: europäischeAlternativreligionen zwischen heidnischer Spiritualität und christlicher Leitkultur, edited by RenéGründer, Michael Schetsche, and Ina Schmied-Knittel. Grenzüberschreitungen, Band 8.Würzburg: Ergon-Verl.Gallagher, Eugene V. 1994. “A Religion without Converts? Becoming a Neo-Pagan.” Journal ofthe American Academy of Religion 62 (3): 851–68.Glaser, Barney G., and Anselm L. Strauss. (1967) 2006. The Discovery of Grounded Theory:Strategies for Qualitative Research. New Brunswick / London: AldineTransaction.Gründer, René. 2008. Germanisches (Neu-)Heidentum im deutschsprachigen Raum. Berlin: Logos.———. 2012. “Neopaganismus im deutschsprachigen Raum. Entwicklungslinien eines neure-ligiösen Feldes.” InMaterialdienst der EZW 10. Berlin: Evangelische Zentralstelle für Weltan-schauungsfragen.Han, Chenxing. 2019. “Contesting ‘Conversion’ and ‘Reversion’ among Young Adult AsianAmerican Buddhists.” Religions 10 (4): 1–18.Harrington, Melissa. 2002. “The long journey home; a study of the conversion profiles of 35British Wiccan men.” Revista de Estudos da Religião 2: 18–55.Harvey, Graham. 1997. Contemporary Neopaganism. Listening People, Speaking Earth. New York:New York University Press.———. 1999. “Coming Home and Coming Out Pagan but not Converting.” In Religious Conver-sion: Contemporary Practices and Controversies (Issues in Contemporary Religion), edited by C.Lamb and D. Bryant. London: Continuum.Hegner, Victoria. 2019. Hexen der Großstadt. Urbanität und neureligiöse Praxis in Berlin. Bielefeld:transcript.Hermosillo, Jaramillo, Belén Citlali, Fernando Plascencia Martínez, and Olivia Sánchez García.2016. “La institucionalización de Wicca en México.” Revista Cultura y Religión 10 (1): 17–30.Hutton, Ronald. 1999. The Triumph of the moon. A history of modern pagan witchcraft. Oxford:Oxford University Press.———. 2015. Contemporary Religion in Historical Perspective: The Case of Modern Paganism.Bristol: University of Bristol.INEGI. 2022. Principales resultados del Censo de Población y Vivienda 2020. Mexico City: INEGI.Jindra, I.W. 2011. “How religious content matters in conversion narratives to various religiousgroups.” Sociology of religion 72 (3): 275–302.Lewis, James R., and Murphy Pizza. 2009. Handbook of Contemporary Paganism. Leiden /Boston: Brill.Lofland, John, and Rodney Stark. 1965. “Becoming a world-saver: A theory of conversion to adeviant perspective.” American Sociological Review 30 (6): 862–75.Luhrmann, Tanya M. 1989. Persuasions of the Witch’s Craft: Ritual Magic in ContemporaryEngland. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Papenfuss Entangled Religions 15.2 (2024)Magliocco, Sabina. 2004. Witching Culture: Folklore and Neo-Paganism in America. University ofPennsylvania Press.Mayer, Gerhard, and René Gründer. 2010. “Coming Home or Drifting Away: Magical Practice inthe Twenty-First Century—Ways of Adopting Heterodox Beliefs and Religious Worldviews.”Journal of Contemporary Religion 25 (3): 395–418. https://doi.org/10.1080/13537903.2010.516550.Medina, Arely. 2019–2020. “Religiones y espiritualidades en la era digital: prácticas, discursose identidades.” Revista Paakat: Revista de Tecnología y Sociedad 17 (9).Pike, Sarah M. 2001. Earthly Bodies, Magical Selves: Contemporary Pagans and the Search forCommunity. Berkeley / Los Angeles: University of California Press.Reid, Síân. 2009. “‘A Religion without Converts’ revisited: Individuals, Identity and Communityin Contemporary Paganism.” In Handbook of contemporary paganism, edited by James R.Lewis and Murphy Pizza. Leiden / Boston: Brill.Rountree, Katheryn. 2015. Contemporary Pagan and Native Faith Movements in Europe. Colonialistand Nationalist Impulses. New York: Berghahn.Schnurbein, Stephanie von. 2016. Norse Revival. Transformations of Germanic Neopaganism.Leiden / Boston: Brill.Straus, Roger. 1976. “Changing oneself: Seekers and the creative transformation of life experi-ence.” In Doing social life, edited by John Lofland. New York: John Wiley.York, Michael. 2003. Pagan Theology: Paganism as a World Religion. New York: New YorkUniversity Press. |
| Clean Full Text | (not set) |
| Language | (not set) |
| Doi | 10.46586/er.15.2024.11593 |
| Arxiv | (not set) |
| Mag | (not set) |
| Acl | (not set) |
| Pmid | (not set) |
| Pmcid | (not set) |
| Pub Date | 2024-06-01 01:00:00 |
| Pub Year | 2024 |
| Journal Name | (not set) |
| Journal Volume | (not set) |
| Journal Page | (not set) |
| Publication Types | (not set) |
| Tldr | (not set) |
| Tldr Version | (not set) |
| Generated Tldr | (not set) |
| Search Term Used | Jehovah's AND yearPublished>=2024 |
| Reference Count | (not set) |
| Citation Count | (not set) |
| Influential Citation Count | (not set) |
| Last Update | 2024-09-15 00:00:00 |
| Status | 0 |
| Aws Job | (not set) |
| Last Checked | (not set) |
| Modified | 2025-01-13 22:06:31 |
| Created | 2025-01-13 22:06:31 |